|
on Sociology of Economics |
| By: | Douglas Cumming |
| Abstract: | Academic journals are part of the infrastructure of science, yet most journal titles are owned by commercial publishers while their standing rests on editors and boards who can leave. This paper asks what that separation means for the governance of science. Using a coded dataset of all 57 editorial mass resignations recorded by Retraction Watch from 2015 to 2026, data on editor tenure at 110 economics, finance and accounting journals, and journal-level publication and revenue data, I document three patterns. First, resignation does not reverse an owner's decision: in none of the 19 episodes involving an editor's replacement did the owner back down after the board resigned, so editorial communities have influence only before they leave. Second, whether a departing board can take a journal's standing with it depends on institutions outside the board: successor journals follow most often where a scholarly society backs the board and rarely in medicine, where non-profit hosts are scarce, while journal ranking lists, which rate titles rather than the people who edit them, keep reputation with the owner. Third, a stated limit on editor tenure was applied at the publisher's discretion; where it was applied, output grew almost fourfold, a short-run gain whose long-run effect on the journal's standing is not yet known. I draw implications for scholarly societies, funders, publishers, and the bodies that compile journal rankings. |
| Date: | 2026–11 |
| URL: | https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:arx:papers:2611.02302 |
| By: | Harris Dellas; Manu García; Carlos Garriga; Christian Zimmermann |
| Abstract: | The tension between diversification and specialization is a central theme in economics, shaping discourse in fields as disparate as international trade, portfolio theory, and corporate scope. This paper examines this trade-off within the realm of research strategy. Using the RePEc panel database of approximately 60, 000 economists, we demonstrate that the pursuit of a diversified research portfolio yields superior performance as measured by citations and publications as well as lower research attrition rates. This advantage applies to both senior and, in contrast to conventional wisdom, early-career researchers. This strategy is significantly facilitated by joint work with new co-authors. |
| Keywords: | research strategy; diversification; specialization; publications; citations; co-authorship; research attrition |
| JEL: | D83 D85 J24 O31 |
| Date: | 2026–11–04 |
| URL: | https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:fip:fedlwp:104020 |
| By: | Herbert, John Michael |
| Abstract: | This work investigates academics and political operatives who use “academic freedom” to camouflage assaults on diversity, equity, and inclusion. Attacks of this sort have appeared in academic journals in recent years, with clickbait headlines decrying “scientific censorship”. The present chapter documents that many of the individuals who promote that narrative are involved with (or at least proximate to) discredited genetic intelligence research, or have defended such lines of inquiry, while others are anti-LGBTQ+ activists. A recurring theme is the suggestion that women in academia are responsible for rising censorship. Meanwhile, these provocateurs have little to say about genuine attacks on academic freedom by the U.S. government, and some are even supportive of government restrictions on research and classroom discussion topics so long as those prohibitions align with a right-wing political agenda. These academics repackage conservative activism beneath a pseudo-intellectual veneer and leverage a media ecosystem that is eager to promote right-wing grievance, acting in alignment with political operatives funded by a network of private foundations that are broadly hostile to higher education. By documenting these connections, the present work serves as a warning that allegations of “scholarship suppression” warrant careful examination of motive. To ignore context is to enable scientific racism, misogyny, and transphobia under guise of “just asking questions”. Academics must acknowledge imperfections in the peer review process and appreciate that attempts to correct the scientific record in light of evolving epistemic standards are not censorship, at least not in a form that ought to be prohibited. |
| Date: | 2026–10–20 |
| URL: | https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:osf:socarx:6kgzs_v1 |
| By: | Matej Bajgar; Suren Karapetyan |
| Abstract: | We examine whether competitive research grants generate independent research by the funded investigator. We distinguish first- and last-author publications—indicating leading contribution in biomedical research—from total output. Using data on Czech medical research grants awarded between 2015 and 2019, we combine a regression discontinuity (RD) design around the funding cutoff with augmented inverse probability weighting (AIPW) that estimates average effects across a broader applicant sample. RD estimates show that grants increase total publications by 3.1 papers (22%). First- and last-author publications increase by 59% and 41% respectively—substantially exceeding the total effect. These gains extend to hightier journals and to citations. AIPW estimates are qualitatively consistent but smaller in magnitude. Within AIPW, first- and last-author effects are larger for funded projects closer to the cutoff, supporting heterogeneity in returns to funding. Exploratory subgroup estimates suggest comparatively large local effects for female and less-senior investigators, although the smaller subgroup samples and differing AIPW patterns mean that these results should be interpreted cautiously. |
| Keywords: | Regression discontinuity design, research funding, scientific productivity |
| JEL: | O38 O30 I23 |
| Date: | 2026–10 |
| URL: | https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:cer:papers:wp824 |
| By: | Hartmann, Eva; Bektemirova, Aikerim |
| Abstract: | Abstract Publications in Scopus- and Web of Science-indexed journals have become the global benchmark of academic excellence. This article examines how Kazakhstan has placed this new ‘gold standard’ at the centre of its academic publishing policy, which has become a key part of its university reform agenda since 2010. Using a Gramscian lens on power and knowledge, we show how the government employs this policy to position itself between the West and Russia in a shifting geopolitical context. The adoption of this benchmark not only changes how Kazakhstan's academic community relates to the broader academic world. It also significantly reshapes the hierarchy within Kazakhstan’s academic community. We argue that this has profound implications for the societal role of universities and academic research and their ability to address local challenges. Our study makes both empirical and theoretical contributions to the growing literature on the geopolitics of knowledge, highlighting the interplay among local, national, and global dynamics. |
| Date: | 2026–10–12 |
| URL: | https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:osf:socarx:48dgy_v1 |
| By: | Manish Dadhich (Udaipur); Bright Akwasi Gyamfi (Selangor, MALAYSIA); Festus Victor Bekun (Istanbul, Turkiye); Sadananda Prusty (Udaipur); Simplice A. Asongu (Johannesburg, South Africa) |
| Abstract: | Research in any discipline establishes the groundwork for advancing knowledge, facilitating learning, and solving problems. Management research is conducive to observing the world and decision-making wonders through a novel outlook. Such research is a fabulous tool for addressing emerging topics and challenges for which scientific data cannot be accessible due to budding awareness of the phenomena. Writing and publishing complement each other and require specific technical knowledge to give a final look for publishing a paper in a top-rating journal. Common challenges subvert authors’ efforts to elucidate their understanding and practice. This paper has identified, articulated, and successfully addressed these hurdles to publishing. A trail guide for different components of a typical research paper is also presented by benchmarking the best business, ethics, and management research practices. This study is the first guideline in writing management papers and is conducive to producing high-quality imperative research for scholars. |
| Keywords: | Influential Writing, Research Framework, Theoretical Background, Writing Challenges, Management Journals |
| Date: | 2025–01 |
| URL: | https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:agd:wpaper:25/023 |
| By: | Qingyuan Chai; Kevin Lang; Liang Zhong |
| Abstract: | We study the statistical credibility of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in development economics and the optimal allocation of resources to replication. Using 745 principal-hypothesis tests from 190 articles in leading economics journals, we find that actual t-statistics peak well below the theoretical benchmark of 2.8 expected under 80 percent power, though above values associated with p-hacking. This suggests many RCTs are underpowered. Estimating an empirical Bayes mixture model that accounts for selective publication, we find that approximately 30 percent of published rejections are false discoveries, with average directional power at only 40 percent. At conventional significance thresholds, the posterior probability of a false discovery reaches 66 percent. Doubling original sample sizes lowers the average false discovery rate by five percentage points, whereas tightening the significance threshold to 0.005 yields a larger reduction at the cost of total discoveries. Finally, we characterize a funder’s optimal replication policy under a fixed budget and an evidence standard. Under standard regularity conditions, replications concentrate in an intermediate interval of original test statistics, and the optimal replication sample size is single-peaked in the original t-statistic. Illustrative calibrations show that successful replications reduce aggregate false discovery rates to 1.8–7.8 percent, depending on the evidence standard. |
| JEL: | C12 C18 O10 O12 |
| Date: | 2026–11 |
| URL: | https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:nbr:nberwo:35999 |
| By: | Little, Zion; Montgomery, Jacob; Schnakenberg, Keith |
| Abstract: | Preregistration has become increasingly prominent across scientific disciplines, with proponents claiming it reduces selective reporting and improves research credibility. Yet its logic is puzzling. Researchers face no formal penalty for straying from their stated plans; indeed, deviations are explicitly condoned. Why should simply announcing a plan change behavior? We address this question by modeling preregistration as a form of cheap talk in a model of private experimentation --- a costless, non-binding announcement that nonetheless shapes reviewer expectations and creates informal discipline through rational belief updating. We show that preregistration can be self-enforcing without any third-party oversight since deviations from an announced plan signal that undisclosed tests failed, and reviewers discount results accordingly. Scientists in our model thus voluntarily choose constraining plans since they lower the evidentiary bar for publication. But the very logic that explains the success of preregistration for enhancing researcher credibility makes its downstream consequences ambiguous. The plans scientists optimally choose retain substantial flexibility for selective reporting while still preserving the credibility benefits of preregistration. The result is that preregistration --- when researchers control plan design --- can produce higher false positive rates than an unrestrictive plan. We discuss how better institutional designs --- such as encouraging disclosure of all preregistered results, and ensuring plans are specific enough that such a norm is meaningful --- would more reliably achieve preregistration's intended goals. |
| Date: | 2026–10–20 |
| URL: | https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:osf:socarx:v7cgj_v1 |
| By: | Andrea Orazio Spinello (CNR-IRCrES, Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche, Istituto di Ricerca sulla Crescita Economica Sostenibile, via dei Taurini 19, Roma – Italia); Danilo Giglitto (Sheffield Hallam University, Howard St, S1 1WB, Sheffield – United Kingdom); Eleanor Lockley (Sheffield Hallam University, Howard St, S1 1WB, Sheffield – United Kingdom) |
| Abstract: | Research funding organizations, particularly at international level, are increasingly promoting the creation and maintenance of open access research infrastructures (RI). These resources have assumed a pivotal role as support for the new open and networked science in their dimension of technical and operational frameworks that allow scientists and stakeholders to collaborate and share scientific data and results. In Social Sciences and Humanities (SSH), the creation and exploitation of open data platforms is still attempting to catch up with longer-standing practices in the “hard sciences†as the resistance to wider data sharing has not yet been completely overcome. This paper aims to describe how a large project, financed by the European Commission, managed the creation of a RI in the field of SSH, showing the steps undertaken to comply with the GDPR regulations and prepare the data for useful sharing and reuse. In this regard, the authors present the case study of the Horizon 2020 “CultureLabs†project, placing emphasis on some specific practical factors that they believe are particularly important for implementing open access principles in the establishment and maintenance of RIs in the new course of science based on sharing and openness. In particular, the authors will focus on creation of “useful†and GDPR-compliant data and the impact on research activities as a result of their (re)utilisation; the control of the data management process; and the compliance with funders’ requirements (e.g. in terms of data security). The reflection on the interplay of these aspects, operated through a case study, appears to be crucial in moving away from a merely theoretical approach to addressing the issue of open access, and it hopes to serve as a guide or a warning for those who create and administer open RIs. |
| Keywords: | open access, GDPR, data management, research infrastructures, SSH |
| URL: | https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:csc:ircrwp:202112 |