Abstract: |
Purpose - The purpose of this paper is to quantify the changes in the
liquidity premium for the real estate equities markets of the United States,
Europe and Asia during the period of 2002 – 2012. The liquidity crisis of
2007-8 had a dramatic impact on returns, valuations and capital raising
abilities of the listed real estate sector globally, and the paper focuses on
understanding and explaining relative liquidity premiums under dynamic market
conditions.Design/methodology/approach - Market liquidity is measured in each
market, U.S, Europe and Asia by analysing liquidity in three different
dimensions of tightness, depth and resilience. We calculate percentage bid-ask
spread as a measure of market tightness, market depth is given by the
Hui-Heubel (HH) liquidity ratio (Hui and Heubel, 1984), while resilience
refers to the speed at which the price fluctuations resulting from trades are
dissipated using a Market-efficient coefficient (MEC) (Hasbrouck and Schwartz,
1988). The company data sample groups securities into large, medium and small
market capitalisations across each of the three regions.Finally the dependency
of real estate firm liquidity with other securities market indicators is
measured in each market, U.S, Europe, Asia by constructing the Hui-Heubel
liquidity ratio on a selection of key companies and correlating this with the
VIX index. A higher HH ratio indicates higher price to volume sensitivity.
Findings - In all three markets bid-ask spreads reduced significantly, and
market liquidity and efficiency increased during the period of 2002 – 2007.
Since that date the results have a more regional bias, and we examine the
reasons behind this. The MEC confirms that European companies exhibit lower
levels of liquidity than their US counterparts, and this a contributing factor
behind periods of relative underperformance. We discovered a high correlation
between market correlation and the VIX Index.Originality/value - The results
provide important clues for investors and real estate companies in pricing
liquidity throughout the cycle and illustrates the regional differences over
the period. This has important implications for investors regarding the
pricing of risk, and absolute and relative returns, and for companies, in
terms of capital raising ability. In addition the finding of the close
relationship between RE stocks liquidity and the VIX index confirms the
importance of equity market influences on public real estate valuations. |