nep-law New Economics Papers
on Law and Economics
Issue of 2026–11–16
ten papers chosen by
Yves Oytana, Université de Franche-Comté


  1. Crime and prices: thefts of expensive precious metals from cars By Foong, Gerald; Machin, Stephen; Sandi, Matteo
  2. Police effectiveness, geographic specialization, police organization By Barrios-Fernandez, Mauricio Andres; Garcia Hombrados, Jorge; Perez-Parra, Daniel
  3. Crime Victims' Children By Paul Bingley; Lorenzo Cappellari; Marco Ovidi; Matteo Sandi
  4. Public salience mobilizes nationwide responses to violence against women By Augusto Cerqua; Marco Letta; Costanza Giannantoni; Gabriele Pinto
  5. Debiasing Law Enforcement Officers: Evidence from an Expressive Arts Intervention in India By Sofia Amaral; Girija Borker; Nishith Prakash; María Micaela Sviatschi
  6. External Shocks and Police Behaviour: Evidence from Terrorist Attacks in the UK By Nils Braakmann; Gennaro Rossi
  7. Policy Evaluation Beyond Significance Testing: Evidence from Chicago's ShotSpotter Contract By Terence Chau; Philip J. Cook; Javier Lopez; Jens Ludwig; Alejandro Roemer; Adam K. Soliman
  8. Gender Identity and Recorded Offending: Evidence from Linked Population Data By Maxine J. Lee; Alexander Plum
  9. Unlawful Tariffs: Incidence, Damages, and Remedies By Roger D. Blair; Javier D. Donna; Gunner Heins
  10. Large Language Models and Ottoman Court Records: Long-Term Change and Regional Comparison By Metin M. Cosgel

  1. By: Foong, Gerald; Machin, Stephen; Sandi, Matteo
    Abstract: Whether economic incentives matter for crime is studied in a novel way, from expensive precious metal thefts by thieves stealing catalytic converters from cars. Sharp and sizable variations in the prices of precious metals embedded in converters are combined with newly assembled U.S. crime data. Precipitously fast increases in precious metal prices generated a sizeable rise in auto-part thefts, while subsequent price declines and policy responses quickly reversed this pattern. The resulting boom-and bust dynamics provide clean evidence that prices affect crime, and for these crimes that local resale infrastructure and target availability shape both the magnitude of this effect and the effectiveness of policy response.
    Keywords: expensive precious metals;auto-part theft;catalytic converters
    JEL: K42 K32
    Date: 2026–10–09
    URL: https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:ehl:lserod:141769
  2. By: Barrios-Fernandez, Mauricio Andres; Garcia Hombrados, Jorge; Perez-Parra, Daniel
    Abstract: This paper provides causal evidence that geographic specialization can significantly enhance police effectiveness. Using rich administrative and survey data from Chile, we examine a major reform that subdivided police operational areas - e.g., municipalities - into smaller zones known as quadrants. On average, each municipality was divided into seven quadrants, with officers permanently assigned to these territories to allow them to develop a deep understanding of their structure, crime patterns, and communities. By exploiting the staggered implementation of the reform across municipalities, we show that this reorganization enhanced police effectiveness along multiple dimensions. Among surveyed households, twelve-month victimization rates declined by 10 percentage points (36%). In line with this result, administrative records from the police reveal a 14% reduction in reported crime. The reform also enhanced public confidence: the share of households reporting high trust in police rose by 12 percentage points (30%), while those perceiving increased criminal activity fell by 15 percentage points (36%). Consequently, the share of households investing in private security measures decreased by 7.7 percentage points (37%). Evidence suggests these improvements stem from geographic specialization, as households in treated municipalities report both greater police presence and better police performance across multiple dimensions associated with a better knowledge of the quadrants and their communities.
    Keywords: police effectiveness;geographic specialization;police organization
    JEL: K42 D73
    Date: 2025–09–03
    URL: https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:ehl:lserod:141533
  3. By: Paul Bingley; Lorenzo Cappellari; Marco Ovidi; Matteo Sandi
    Abstract: Crime can disrupt victims’ working lives and family circumstances, potentially affecting the environment in which their children develop. We provide causal evidence that non-domestic parental victimization harms children’s human capital. Using Danish registers, we implement a matched difference-in-differences design that exploits victimization timing relative to the end of compulsory schooling. Violent victimization reduces mathematics scores by 0.03 standard deviations on average, reaching 0.09 following paternal victimization in early childhood, while property victimization has no detectable effect. Violent victimization of mothers disrupts educational progression, particularly for daughters. Sons experience lower well-being, while daughters report greater perceived safety and have lower rates of police-recorded victimization. Achievement losses are larger in families predicted to experience weaker parental labor-market attachment, a greater likelihood of parental charges for violent crime, and greater relational or residential instability.
    Keywords: parental criminal victimization, intergenerational spillovers, children’s human capital, early childhood
    JEL: K42 I24 J13
    Date: 2026
    URL: https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:ces:ceswps:_13141
  4. By: Augusto Cerqua; Marco Letta; Costanza Giannantoni; Gabriele Pinto
    Abstract: Does public salience around femicides mobilize societal responses or trigger further harm through imitation? Using newly assembled case-level data on femicides in Italy from 2017 to 2024, we study the nationwide consequences of the most salient cases for help-seeking, police reporting, and lethal violence. We find that highly salient intimate partner femicides (IPFs) generate nationwide increases in help-seeking, and that an exceptionally salient IPF also leads to a marked rise in police reports of violence against women. Yet we find no evidence of an increase in femicides-a pattern inconsistent with copycat theories. Responses are strongest during periods of peak salience. No comparable mobilization follows a lower-salience IPF, a similarly salient femicide committed by family members, a highly salient killing of a woman not classified as a femicide, or a lower-salience falsification case. Together, these comparisons indicate that mobilization depends on salience intensity, the victim-perpetrator relationship, and the gendered nature of the violence, rather than reflecting a generic response to salient violent crime. These findings suggest that public salience can contribute to prevention strategies against gender-based violence without amplifying lethal violence.
    Date: 2026–11
    URL: https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:arx:papers:2611.02647
  5. By: Sofia Amaral; Girija Borker; Nishith Prakash; María Micaela Sviatschi
    Abstract: Frontline state agents exercise substantial discretion over citizens’ access to public services, yet little is known about whether the attitudes and beliefs shaping this discretion can be changed among incumbent bureaucrats. Partnering with the Bihar Police - one of India’s largest states that operates under comparatively severe policing capacity constraints, we conduct a cluster randomized controlled trial across 417 police stations and roughly 2, 500 active duty senior field police officers to evaluate a three-day expressive arts intervention, grounded in the Theatre of the Oppressed, designed to change police responses to gender-based violence (GBV). Approximately 7 months after baseline, treated officers exhibit more favorable attitudes toward GBV, greater empathy, and stronger legal knowledge. These changes translate into observed policing behavior: in standardized victim audits conducted one year later, officers in treated stations are 15 percentage points less likely to blame victims, dismiss fewer complaints, and provide more referrals, while administrative records show a 41 percent reduction in registration delays and, over a longer horizon, increased GBV reporting by citizens. Exploiting variation generated by officer transfers, we find suggestive evidence that these effects persist when treated officers relocate and diffuse to untreated officers working alongside treated colleagues. The effects also extend to the workplace: junior female officers working with treated senior officers report lower harassment and anxiety. These findings show that the attitudes shaping bureaucratic discretion are malleable and that changing how incumbent state agents exercise authority can improve both citizen-facing service delivery and the broader workplace environment.
    JEL: O10 P0
    Date: 2026–11
    URL: https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:nbr:nberwo:35986
  6. By: Nils Braakmann (Business School – Economics, Newcastle University); Gennaro Rossi (Department of Economics, University of Reading)
    Abstract: Shocks, such as terrorist attacks, may shift policing through profiling (group-targeted enforcement driven by salience) or operational changes. We test these channels using administrative data from London’s Metropolitan Police Service on use-of-force incidents and stop-and-searches, linked to UK terrorist attacks between April 2017 and November 2019. Exploiting attack timing in a regression discontinuity-in-time design, we compare outcomes in narrow windows around each event. Across both datasets we find little evidence of short-run ethnic profiling after Muslim extremist or far-right attacks. In contrast, Muslim extremist attacks – substantially more lethal in our sample – are followed by a shift toward weapons searches, more public-protection-focused force, and greater use-of-force intensity for both White and Non-white subjects. The evidence is consistent with heightened alertness rather than discriminatory targeting.
    Keywords: policing, terrorism, use of force, stop and search, salience, bias
    JEL: K42 J15 D74 C21
    Date: 2026–11–05
    URL: https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:rdg:emxxdp:em-dp2026-11
  7. By: Terence Chau; Philip J. Cook; Javier Lopez; Jens Ludwig; Alejandro Roemer; Adam K. Soliman
    Abstract: Program impact estimates that are not statistically significant are often treated as providing little guidance for policy choice, even when economically important effects remain plausible. In such cases, the decision-relevant task is not simply to test whether the effect differs from zero, but to estimate the probability distribution of programmatic effects. The importance of going beyond hypothesis testing is especially clear when evaluations are underpowered relative to the effect needed for benefits to exceed costs. We illustrate this point using Chicago’s contract for ShotSpotter, an acoustical gunshot detection system that reduces police response times and may therefore have improved survival among shooting victims. Using a geographic RD design, we estimate that ShotSpotter reduced the shooting fatality rate by 2.5 percentage points, equivalent to roughly 49 fewer deaths per year. Although the estimate is not statistically significant, its implied benefit far exceeds the cost of the service. To have enough statistical power under the hypothesis testing approach to detect an effect of this size would require 87 years’ worth of Chicago shooting data. We instead implement a decision-relevant perspective using Bayesian analysis, treating the life-saving effect as a random variable. We find positive expected net benefits, with posterior probabilities that benefits exceed costs ranging from 70% under a flat prior and a $0.5 million value of statistical life to 99.6% under a no-harm prior and a $13.6 million value. The results illustrate how reliance on statistical significance can discard decision-relevant evidence when economically meaningful effects are difficult to detect precisely.
    JEL: C10 C12 C44 K42
    Date: 2026–11
    URL: https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:nbr:nberwo:36005
  8. By: Maxine J. Lee (San Francisco State University); Alexander Plum (Auckland University of Technology)
    Abstract: Population evidence on gender identity and offending remains scarce. We link New Zealand’s 2023 Census to administrative records for 170, 775 New Zealand-born individuals from the 1993–1998 birth cohorts. Separate measures of sex at birth and gender distinguish six groups: cisgender women, cisgender men, transgender women, transgender men, and nonbinary individuals grouped by sex assigned at birth. Their histories of selected Police-recorded interpersonal and victim-related offenses are examined over a common ten-year window at ages 17–26. Adjusting for ethnicity, parental income, parental sentencing history, and year-month of birth, all four gender-minority groups have significantly lower odds of a qualifying record than cisgender men. For transgender women, the adjusted probability is 5.1%, compared with 12.2% for cisgender men and 6.0% for cisgender women. The corresponding differences are −7.2 and −1.0 percentage points; only the former is statistically significant. Across the main analyses of offense type, court action, victim characteristics, and location, transgender women consistently have lower adjusted probabilities than cisgender men, while differences from cisgender women are not statistically significant. These findings document variation in recorded offending obscured by conventional binary classifications.
    Keywords: gender identity, police-recorded offending, linked administrative data
    JEL: K42 J16 J15
    Date: 2026–11–11
    URL: https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:aut:wpaper:2026-05
  9. By: Roger D. Blair (University of Florida); Javier D. Donna (University of Miami); Gunner Heins (University of Florida)
    Abstract: In Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump, the Supreme Court held that the tariffs imposed by executive order pursuant to the International Emergency Economic Powers Act exceeded presidential authority. The decision has generated over two thousand lawsuits and potential refund exposure in the range of $130–175 billion. This Article provides a law and economics analysis of the recovery problem. Drawing on the Bigelow measure of antitrust damages and standard tax incidence theory, the Article argues that both importers and foreign exporters have suffered cognizable injury. The damage suffered by each class depends on the incidence of the tariff, which is determined by the elasticities of domestic import demand and foreign export supply. The Article examines the complications introduced by market power, supply-chain pass-on under Illinois Brick, the problem of windfalls, and the econometric challenges of estimating the but-for price. Methodological approaches—including before-and-after comparisons, yardstick methods, and structural demand estimation—are evaluated. The Article also addresses the social welfare loss not captured by private damage claims and the procedural constraint imposed by the 180-day customs protest period.
    Keywords: Unlawful tariffs, IEEPA, tariff incidence, antitrust damages, but-for price, Illinois Brick, pass-on defense, customs refund, trade policy
    JEL: K21 F13 K33 H22 K41
    Date: 2026–11
    URL: https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:aoz:wpaper:412
  10. By: Metin M. Cosgel (University of Connecticut)
    Abstract: Large language models offer new ways to turn historical texts into quantitative evidence, but their value depends on whether the resulting data support reliable comparisons. I examine that potential through Ottoman court registers, a source for studying long-term change and regional variation after regular tax surveys ceased around 1600. I combine rule-based extraction with large language models to convert 385 transcribed volumes from twelve districts into a dataset of 160, 395 entries. Rules extract formulaic information, while models classify documents, identify participants’ roles, and interpret legal outcomes. Validation uses hand-coded samples and comparisons with three published Istanbul studies of intergenerational persistence of social standing, foreign-coin use, and the decisive oath in litigation. The new extraction recovers their principal patterns and adds later observations to the standing and oath series. Applying common definitions across districts reveals different relationships between the capital and the provinces. The oath’s early seventeenth-century peak and subsequent decline appear broadly across the observed courts. Foreign silver accounted for substantial shares of recorded transaction value earlier in Antep, Amasya, and Kayseri than in Istanbul and several western and central districts. The early seventeenth-century decline in father–son status persistence in Istanbul was shared by Bursa but was not a general provincial pattern. Uneven transcription coverage, selection into court, and extraction error limit these comparisons. Within those limits, the method makes published court records usable for comparative quantitative history across several centuries and regions.
    Keywords: Ottoman Empire; court records; sicil; tahrir; quantitative history; long-run change; regional comparison; large language models
    JEL: N01 N35 N45 N95 C81 K40
    Date: 2026–11
    URL: https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:uct:uconnp:2026-04

This nep-law issue is ©2026 by Yves Oytana. It is provided as is without any express or implied warranty. It may be freely redistributed in whole or in part for any purpose. If distributed in part, please include this notice.
General information on the NEP project can be found at https://nep.repec.org. For comments please write to the director of NEP, Marco Novarese at <director@nep.repec.org>. Put “NEP” in the subject, otherwise your mail may be rejected.
NEP’s infrastructure is sponsored by the Griffith Business School of Griffith University in Australia.