nep-law New Economics Papers
on Law and Economics
Issue of 2026–11–09
six papers chosen by
Yves Oytana, Université de Franche-Comté


  1. Prison, Probation, and the Community By Kang, Sam
  2. How does judges' personal exposure to financial fraud affect white-collar sentencing? By Nguyen, Trung; Raghunandan, Aneesh; Scherf, Alexa
  3. Litigation as a "win-win" game: A Theoretical Perspective and Empirical Evidence from Brazilian Labor Courts By Luciana Yeung; Antonio Bruno de Carvalho Morales
  4. Demystifying Unconscionability: A Historical and Empirical Analysis By McCall, Brian M.
  5. Dismissing Human Trafficking: Forced Arbitration of Survivors’ Civil Suits By Smith, Annie; Werner, Daniel
  6. First-Month Check-Ins as an Early Indicator in Pretrial Supervision By Johnston, Cliff Hurt; Green, Ted; Warren, Madeline

  1. By: Kang, Sam
    Abstract: This paper examines how incarceration and probation shape community crime rates with 20 years of administrative court records from Milwaukee, Wisconsin. I estimate causal effects by instrumenting for a criminal defendant's sentence with the preferences of a randomly assigned judge. I extend the canonical randomized judge design framework to incorporate effects generated along the intensive margin of sentence durations. This framework allows me to distinguish between effects to the marginally incarcerated defendant from effects to non-marginal defendants. Empirically, I find that sentencing effects are driven by extensions in the duration of incarceration, with one additional year preventing an estimated 17% of defendant reconvictions and an additional 4% of neighbor convictions during the subsequent five years. Heterogeneity analyses reveal that spillover effects are driven by violent felony offenders, indicating that incapacitating high-risk offenders generates additional social benefits in the neighborhood.
    Keywords: Incarceration, probation, randomized judges, neighborhood effects, instrumental variables, heterogeneous treatment effects, continuous treatments
    JEL: K42 R23 C36
    Date: 2026
    URL: https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:zbw:glodps:1838
  2. By: Nguyen, Trung; Raghunandan, Aneesh; Scherf, Alexa
    Abstract: We study whether federal judges’ personal exposure to financial fraud affects their professional behavior, in the form of sentencing outcomes in white-collar cases. Following the methodology outlined in our registered report, we construct a novel measure of financial fraud exposure based on judges’ direct shareholdings in firms that commit financial fraud. Using this measure, we exploit the random assignment of cases to judges to examine whether judges exposed to fraud in one firm are (1) less likely to rule in favor of defendants in white-collar cases involving other firms and (2) less likely to grant favorable pretrial motions to defendants. We find minimal evidence in support of either (1) or (2), concluding that for all but the most serious frauds, judges are unlikely to let their personal victimhood experience affect their professional sentencing behavior with respect to related cases. Our study broadens our understanding of the spillover effects of financial fraud enforcement and contributes to the literature on how judges’ personal experiences can shape judicial decision-making.
    Keywords: fraud;judge biases;personal financial disclosure;white-collar crime
    JEL: M40
    Date: 2025–05–31
    URL: https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:ehl:lserod:124397
  3. By: Luciana Yeung; Antonio Bruno de Carvalho Morales
    Abstract: Employers in Brazilian labor courts are ordered to pay something in roughly nine of every ten adjudicated claims, and a composition is available at any time at a fraction of what a judgment costs them. Yet large employers decline to compose, claim after claim, for years. We show that this is the equilibrium of a repeated game in which a long-lived defendant faces a continuing flow of short-lived claimants who differ in the personal cost of carrying a claim. The defendant is not buying a cheaper resolution of the present claim; it is buying a public record of refusing to compose, which lengthens the expected duration of any claim brought against it and thins the flow of claims it will face in future. The mechanism requires neither divergent beliefs about the merits nor private information. Three results carry the argument. A reputation for toughness deters entry if and only if the ratio of the two values at stake is smaller than the ratio of the two delays, each measured as a discounted annuity, a condition that is automatic when compositions price at the claimant’s reservation value. Because claimants differ, deterrence is always partial and the filing rate is bounded away from zero at every reputation the defendant can attain, so the stationary outcome is persistent litigation rather than its disappearance. And permanent toughness requires the defendant’s patience to exceed a threshold that falls with the responsiveness of entry and with the speed at which the market’s record forms. We take the model to approximately 130, 000 decisions of Brazil’s largest regional labor court (TRT-2, São Paulo) for 2001–2017, obtained by text mining. The corpus establishes the institutional configuration the model assumes: court-fee waivers granted essentially automatically and held by 84.7% of claimants, no exposure of the losing claimant to the employer’s attorney fees, and contingent representation, which together produce a lottery with no losing ticket and guarantee participation at any degree of risk aversion. It also establishes the constraint that forces our definition of reputation, since an employer that disputes everything still loses most of what it disputes and cannot build a record of victories. We do not report a calibration: composition rates are not observable in a corpus of decisions, and we set out what would be needed to measure the model’s remaining objects.
    Keywords: Litigation, Ligation, litigation, settlement, labor courts, repeated games, reputation, risk aversion, text mining
    JEL: K41 C72 C73 J52 K31
    Date: 2026–08–09
    URL: https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:gvn:eprgwp:1242026
  4. By: McCall, Brian M.
    Abstract: The doctrine of unconscionability is encrusted with myths. First-year law students are taught that the doctrine was created in the twentieth century. Unconscionability is often presented as a novel one, born in the Uniform Commercial Code’s adoption of Section 2-302 in the mid-twentieth century. Even those scholars who are willing to look a bit further afield than the twentieth century for the origins of the unconscionability doctrine typically only reach the mid-eighteenth century. In addition to myths surrounding its origin, the doctrine has been presented as a dangerously vague and imprecise concept. Commentators and scholars have likewise characterized the doctrine as a license for courts to refuse, unpredictably and arbitrarily, to enforce some contracts. Some claim its application has the potential to destroy all of contract law. Beyond the fearmongering myths, another standard myth taught to first-year law students is that to succeed on a claim of unconscionability a party must offer at least some proof of both procedural and substantive unconscionability. This Article will thus attempt to dispel the following three myths about unconscionability: • It is a new, modern doctrine of law, • Its application is unpredictable and arbitrary, and • To prevail a party must prove both procedural and substantive unconscionability. The best way to dispel myths is through facts. This Article attempts to clear the clouds of confusion and fear surrounding the doctrine by turning to historical and empirical fact. Part I of this Article looks to the ancient past and finds that the idea that justice, and hence the law, should grant a remedy to at least some people who enter into inequitable bargains, is as old as philosophizing about justice itself (and certainly older than the mid-eighteenth century). Rather than a dangerous modern innovation, this principle of justice has ancient philosophical roots in Aristotle and ancient legal roots in Roman law. Part II of the Article summarizes prior attempts to assess the doctrine of unconscionability through empirical research by summarizing the results of prior work and identifies the limited scope of those projects. Part III contains the results of the comprehensive empirical analysis of what appears to be happening in cases involving claims of unconscionability in the period 2013–2017. A comprehensive coding process was undertaken for all reported federal and state cases decided over this five-year period. The results of the data analysis of 463 federal and state cases suggest that whatever the casebooks and law review articles claim about the doctrine, its application in real courts on the ground is very predictable and simpler than a two-part requirement suggests. The Article concludes with a proposal to reformulate the doctrine to conform better to both its historical roots and its application by courts in real cases.
    Date: 2026–10–22
    URL: https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:osf:lawarc:rmpfh_v1
  5. By: Smith, Annie; Werner, Daniel
    Abstract: For more than two decades, federal law has provided trafficked individuals the right to sue their traffickers in court and hundreds of survivors have filed suit. Their litigation has yielded millions in judgments and settlements, public accountability, development of the law, and a deeper understanding of human trafficking. Forced arbitration of human trafficking claims threatens these successes. Much has been written about the existence and enforcement of pre-dispute arbitration clauses, particularly in employment and consumer matters. This Article is the first to assess these pervasive contractual provisions in the context of human trafficking. It sets out the public and private functions of the federal private right of action for trafficking survivors. Informed by federal cases where alleged traffickers successfully compelled arbitration, the Article details how these important functions are undermined by forced arbitration and how the harms of human trafficking are exacerbated by it. Compelling arbitration of survivors’ civil claims erodes government efforts to combat human trafficking and to support survivors. This Article makes two recommendations to address this deepening and underappreciated problem. First, Congress should amend the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) to invalidate pre-dispute arbitration provisions in cases involving human trafficking. Second, the regulations governing temporary work visas for foreign nationals should prohibit pre-dispute arbitration provisions in their employment contracts. In the meantime, survivors can continue to challenge these provisions in court using contract defenses.
    Date: 2026–10–15
    URL: https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:osf:lawarc:ajqdn_v1
  6. By: Johnston, Cliff Hurt; Green, Ted; Warren, Madeline
    Abstract: Pretrial supervision has a short window to keep a person on track to resolve their case without returning to jail, and most of what agencies use to set supervision intensity is fixed at booking. Published pretrial research has found static factors such as criminal history and prior failures to appear more predictive than dynamic ones (Bechtel, Lowenkamp, & Holsinger, 2011), but the findings reported here may challenge that conclusion. This paper asks whether something RePath records from the first day of supervision, the share of scheduled app check-ins a participant completes in the first 30 days, says anything about how the case ends. We examined Missouri pretrial cases across 65 agencies that closed successfully or unsuccessfully between October 1, 2025 and September 30, 2026 and were open at least 30 days (4, 833 closures). Among the 1, 504 cases with check-ins scheduled in the first month, participants whose cases closed successfully had completed 68.9% of them and those whose cases closed unsuccessfully 47.3%, a gap of 21.6 points (95% CI 17.2 to 26.0; Cohen's d = 0.67). Participants who completed fewer than half closed unsuccessfully 32.9% of the time, against 14.2% for the rest (risk ratio 2.31). The unsuccessful-closure rate was highest among participants who completed little or none of their first-month check-ins (39.5% at zero) and lowest among those who completed nearly all of them (7.9% at 90–99%; none of 26 at 100%), and first-month completion separated outcomes with an AUC of .69 (95% CI .66 to .72), within the range reported for two validated pretrial risk tools, the Public Safety Assessment (.55–.68) and the federal Pretrial Risk Assessment (.67–.73), though the populations, outcomes and timing differ. The gap held across case-length floors, within agencies, and with excluded closures recoded either way. We report the result with its boundaries: one state, one year, outcomes as provided by agencies, technical revocations and new arrests not separable, and no claim that raising check-in completion changes outcomes. The finding supports first-month check-in completion as an early indicator that gives agencies useful information to act on, with no added assessment burden.
    Date: 2026–10–15
    URL: https://d.repec.org/n?u=RePEc:osf:lawarc:2a5r6_v1

This nep-law issue is ©2026 by Yves Oytana. It is provided as is without any express or implied warranty. It may be freely redistributed in whole or in part for any purpose. If distributed in part, please include this notice.
General information on the NEP project can be found at https://nep.repec.org. For comments please write to the director of NEP, Marco Novarese at <director@nep.repec.org>. Put “NEP” in the subject, otherwise your mail may be rejected.
NEP’s infrastructure is sponsored by the Griffith Business School of Griffith University in Australia.